Thomas Kean, president of Drew University and former Republican
governor of New Jersey, did not mince words. "Ours may be the first society
in history to neglect children during early adolescence, the years 10
through 14," he said. "Western European societies offered apprenticeship
programs; tribal societies had initiation rites to help young people cross
into adulthood.What do we offer them?" Wine coolers packaged like soft
drinks.
Kean was speaking at a meeting of the Carnegie Council, which, on
October 13, 1995 brought together 200 people from around the nation to discuss
the conditions faced by adolescents, "the most neglected Americans,"
according to Carnegie's new report, "Great Transitions." Much of the
report's findings were disturbingly familiar. Among them:
One-third of eighth-graders (typically 13-year-olds) report the
use of illicit drugs, including inhalants. Among eighth-graders, the rate
of smoking rose by 30 percent between 1992 and 1994.
Among sexually experienced girls 13 years old and younger, over
60 percent have had involuntary intercourse. The greatest rate of increased
births during adolescence is occurring for girls younger than 15.
Among 10- through 14-year-olds, the firearm homicide rate more
than doubled for victims in this age group between 1985 and 1992.
Self-destructive violence, particularly the rate of suicide among
10- to 14-year-olds, increased 120 percent between 1980 and 1992. Suicide
increased most dramatically among young black males and young white
females.
Twenty-seven percent of eighth-graders spend two or more hours at
home alone after school, placing them at significantly higher risk of
self-destructive and violent behavior.
Despite the depressing news, we should not forget that many teens
successfully leap the chasm between childhood and adulthood.
"Alarm is not enough," said David Hamburg, president of the
Carnegie Corp., which oversees the Council's work. Based on what is now
known from recent research of healthy adolescents and families, he said,
there is much that can be done. "What does it take for an adolescent to
successfully leap the chasm?" he asked. "Here's a crack at the answers."
A successful adolescent, he said, finds a valued place in a
constructive group; learns how to have constructive relationships; learns
how to make informed choices; expresses constructive curiosity; finds ways
to be useful to other people; learns lifelong learning habits; values
democracy; and finds ways to believe in the future.
Helping a teenager achieve all of this isn't easy; but parents
often have more power than they think they do.
For many years, parents have thought that the parent-teen conflict
was natural," said Eleanor Maccoby, professor of psychology at Stanford
University, and a member of the Council. "The conventional wisdom was that
the kids should fight to be free from their parents, and their parents
should give up control as gracefully as possible, and that if the right
values had not been installed in the child by this age, it was too late."
However, current research is more hopeful, she said. Adolescents
should, in fact, be allowed to act more independently, but parents and
teens should not disengage. "Rather, they should move toward the kind of
relationship that adults, who are close, have with one another."
Maccoby's description of this relationship was fascinating. Adults
who are close are never totally autonomous. They maintain their
relationship within a binding network; agree to coordinate activities,
negotiate the division of labor; and try to show up on time for meetings
with each other. This, she said, is the relationship that parents and
adolescents need to move toward, rather than total independence from each
other.
"One of the indicators that a parent and an adolescent are truly
close," she added, "is that the parent has a tremendous amount of knowledge
about the child's life, even if the parent is divorced and living in a
separate household."
To encourage this kind of family relationship, parents and children
need much more help from institutions, said Hamburg. "In the elementary
schools, we found a surprising amount of parental involvement. But after
that, it goes over a cliff. We need to educate parents that when they stay
involved in the schools, their adolescents do much better."
He recommended that middle schools and junior highs be more
aggressive in reaching out to parents. They could, for example, sponsor
support groups for parents of adolescents.
To help kids stay connected to adults and supportive peers, large
junior high schools should be broken up into smaller "schools within the
school," said Hamburg. The Council also recommended that life sciences
curriculums in middle and junior high schools be strengthened and that
school health facilities be expanded and kept open after school hours.
One point reverberated throughout the Council's research:
Adolescents need a sense of community, not only among their peers but among
adults of all ages.
Hamburg called for intensified efforts by the organizations that
already serve youth -- the YMCAs and YWCAs -- but also added effort by
religious organizations, museums, Kiwanians, Rotarians and other
traditional service groups. Many of these organizations, he said, are
already doing good things for teens, "but the scale is too small."
Joseph Califano, a former Secretary of Health, Education and
Welfare, argued for more business involvement, if only out of business
self-interest. "We now know that virtually all substance abusers get hooked
before 21," he said. "Because of substance abuse, American business lost
$60 billion last year in lost productivity alone."
Califano, now chairman of Columbia University's Center on Addiction
and Substance Abuse, challenged businesses to provide family-friendly work
policies; extend health insurance to dependent adolescents (one in seven
has no health coverage); provide substance abuse programs to employees with
adolescent drug or alcohol problems; provide seed money for after-school
programs for teens, and think about how corporate advertising and marketing
plays on adolescent fears and vulnerability.
Carnegie's recommendations "are not Utopian," said Hamburg.
"Working model programs can be observed across the country; some have been
scrutinized by good evaluative research. But where a few are found, we need
thousands."
Richard Louv is Senior Editor of Connect for Kids and columnist for
The San Diego Union-Tribune. He is also author of "101 Things
You Can Do for Our Children's Future" (Anchor) and "The Web of
Life" (Conari).