logo
Published on Connect for Kids / Child Advocacy 360 / Youth Policy Action Center (http://www.connectforkids.org)

Phys-Ed Revolution

Published: October 13, 2003

by: Susan Phillips

It's tough being an adolescent,even tougher being an overweight adolescent. But itseems like modern life conspires to make it difficultfor teens to stay fit and active. Community oppositionwipes out plans for a skateboard park, but your bestfriend has Tony Hawk's Pro Skater for Play Station.You used to play soccer during recess—but inmiddle school, it's about shooting hoops andgirls aren't welcome. Plus, everyone is watching.

It's not surprising that physical activitylevels drop and rates of overweight and obesity climbin the middle school years. But it's a trendworth fighting, insists George Graham, president ofthe National Association for Sport and Physical Educationand a professor of kinesiology at Pennsylvania StateUniversity. Graham spoke with Connect for Kids'editor Susan Phillips about the challenge of keepingkids moving in middle school.

Are certain groups of adolescentsat particular risk of obesity and being overweight?

Certainly girls are more at risk than boys, there's no question about that. African American, Hispanic,and Native American kids are also more at risk. We see the big increase in obesity coming between theages of 12 and 18, from about the time they start middle school.

You've been activein the area of school-based physical education forabout 30 years now. How has PE changed?

It's better in a lot of ways. Twenty years agoit was common to see captains picking teams. I liketo think today that is rare. That's a huge change,it really hurts kids to constantly be picked last... There's an emphasis more on sports and physicalactivities that youngsters can do for a lifetime,as opposed to just team sports. Things like golf,tennis, badminton, rock climbing, roller-skating.

What if parents feel thata school's program isn't fitting in withkids' needs?

Parents should know that there's no supportfor an old-style program. If they see kids pickingteams, things like that, parents have a legitimatecase for going to the administration and saying, "Thisdoes not reflect what we know works today in physicaleducation."

Are middle school and highschool kids spending more or less time in the gymand on the playing field now than in the past?

Probably less time, though we don't have gooddata on that. We know that in terms of requirements,particularly at high school level, we have less physicaleducation than we used to.

Why is that? Has schoolreform had an impact?

Yes. No Child Left Behind at this point has not been a good friend to kids' bodies, though it maybe a good friend to their heads. Some of us might say we're being irresponsible, because we talk about education of the whole child, but it's really not, it's just the head.

There's a lot of competition for kids'time, and a lot of the attractive options don'trequire much physical effort—video games, computergames, TV, instant messaging. What are some successfulstrategies for keeping middle-schoolers involved inphysical activities?

The most important thing is that it has to startearlier than middle school—parents and schoolsneed to help kids find activities they really likeand enjoy, as much as they enjoy watching televisionor as much as playing video games. Unfortunately forfar too many kids, there's nothing that theyreally like enough, that they enjoy enough, that theyreally want to do it. So then here comes middle school,and the body changes, and it's not cool to dothings with parents, and you can't be on theteam unless you're already good.

It's tough to get kids turned on to new sports and activities in middle school, for a lot of psychological and social reasons. But young children love to move. That's the time to introduce them to sports, all different kinds of activities, and then hopefully they can grab on to a couple and bring that along into middle school. Hopefully not just team sports, but if they happen to like something like skiing, or in-line skating, or certain kinds of dance, maybe cycling, that's all key.

But what if it's too late for that? Is there any way to get an un-athletic middle school student moving?

My God, it's hard to take a middle school kid, overweight and out of shape, and get him or her turned on to physical activity. All the standard advice—"Go for a walk with your parents, do sit ups and pushups during commercials"—I mean, sure. All that stuff, it doesn't work.

It has to be something they want to do, something they can do with friends. I'm a big advocate of skateboard parks. I know there is a bad stigma attached to that culture, but it does appeal to alot of kids who may not be that team athlete kind of kid. And it's a wonderful sport, in terms of physical activity, in terms of workout, in terms of balance. There's a video game, called Dance Dance Revolution, some kids just take to it, they just love it, they can't get enough of it, particularly girls. There's a home version as well as anarcade version.

As a parent, you need to be thinking, how can I arrangefor my son or my daughter and their friends to dosomething together? If you can get something set upfor them to do as a group, that might work.

How can school physicaleducation programs meet the needs of kids who aren'tathletic, kids who are overweight?

Well, it's hard to generalize. You certainly need to avoid anything that can be publicly humiliating. Something like volleyball, where you have to serve and you can't, and everyone gets on you about that. That's really embarrassing.

Some places are setting up rock-climbing walls, thatcan grab some kids... And pedometers can work for some kids. It's a personal kind of a thing,you can set your own goals. If you're doing 3,000 steps a day, you can shoot for 3,500, and you can check through the day and see how you're doing, but no one else needs to know anything about it, just keep the cover closed on your pedometer.

Heart-rate monitors can be motivating for some kids.

Should schools be providing information on healthy foods and nutrition as well?

Well, kids need to have that information. I just don't know how successful that is for motivating kids to change their behavior. I don't think it works to say to kids, "This is bad for your health." For middle school kids, 30 is ancient. If you tell them something is going to happen when they are 50, they are going to look at you like you're crazy.

How often should schools have physical education?

It should take place every day. That happens all overthe country, but in different pockets. The state of Illinois requires PE every day, but then there are so many exemptions that a lot of kids don't really have it every day... Some places have daily PE, but they put 100 kids in a class, so that's not conducive to really learning. Texas and North Carolina have passed legislation to include physical activity in the school day—that's notphysical education, necessarily. At least they are recognizing the importance of physical activity.

Resources:

Susan Phillips is the former executive editor for Connect for Kids.



Source URL:
http://www.connectforkids.org/node/510